Welcome to Pauly's Pizzeria & Sub Co.
At Pauly's Pizzeria & Sub Co., a hidden gem in Rapid City, flavors come alive. Born from a passion for quality ingredients, this locally owned establishment offers mouthwatering pizzas, hearty subs, and irresistible starters. Guests rave about the garlic parmesan knots and Wisconsin cheese curds, perfectly paired with warm marinara sauce. The menu boasts specialty offerings like the oversized meatball sub and the West Coast Club, each crafted to satisfy cravings. With a welcoming atmosphere and devoted staff, Pauly's is not just a place to eat, but a community favorite where every meal is a celebration of exceptional flavor and heart.
Pauly's Pizzeria & Sub Co.: Reviews & Ratings
Fantastic pizza, great beer wall, and friendly staff. Kids loved it and we will definitely be back!
I’ve been searching for a locally owned (non-franchise) pizza place to try out and I found this place today. I was pleasantly surprised. We ordered the plain pizza and garlic knots and my whole family was impressed. Not one lick of a leftover. This is going to be my new go-to pizza place.
Excellent service, the pizza and cheese sticks were amazing!! The owner came out and is super nice and likes to know if his customers are happy with everything. It was a great experience with great food!
Since I could remember, this place has excellent food. Hands down the BEST potato bacon soup! :). Been coming here for may years and never been disappointed. I would recommend 100%
Stopped here on vacation. Friendly service. Awesome cheese pizza. My husband and I shared the Greek salad, and it was huge and delicious. The cheese bread was great! Lots of options. If you are in Rapid City and you like pizza, check this place out!
Best pizza in Rapid City!! It has an amazing flavor, and I love the texture of the corn mill on the crust, gives it extra crispiness and crunch. The pepperoni are small, which I feel like make some better. Somehow I always love the tiny pepperonis. Definitely recommend if you’re looking for some pizza. But they are NOT open on the weekends. So be sure to get your pizza fix taken care of during the week.
Aside from having amazing food, and a fun beer wall, the staff is amazing. The owner saw me get out of my car and unload my stroller and met me at the door to open it for me. So kind!
100/5 Exceptional Service! This is what REAL customer service looks like! Ask for Jeff when ordering - he is a great help. Special request or forget to add something to your sandwich? Jeff is on it! The pizza are freaking amazing! I think this is the BEST pizza in 6 states! The crust and everything is prepared IN HOUSE/HOMEMADE! Want frozen go somewhere else! If an employee comes in to eat here on her day off - what does that tell you!?!? She just knows regardless of her not working, it’s fabulous! The bathrooms are clean and labeled “family restroom.” This makes me happy, no stereotypes! Brian, the owner - a true business man who has happy employees! Get here during the week - Monday through Friday because he gives his employees the weekends off! Happy employees perform and ensure they work to ensure your satisfaction!
Location
-
1624 E Saint Patrick St, Rapid City, SD 57703, United States Hotline:
Welcome to Pauly's Pizzeria & Sub Co., a cherished gem nestled in the heart of Rapid City, South Dakota. Located at 1624 E Saint Patrick St, this locally owned establishment has become a beloved spot for pizza lovers and sandwich enthusiasts alike. Emphasizing quality and flavor, Pauly's holds a reputation for offering fantastic food and exceptional service.
As you step inside, the warm and inviting atmosphere embraces you. Families sit together enjoying piping hot pizzas while sharing laughter and stories. The friendly staff, with their genuine smiles, make you feel right at home, ensuring that each visit is memorable.
- Pizza Selection: Pauly's menu boasts an array of mouthwatering pizzas that cater to all taste preferences. Dive into the ALota Italy Pizza, featuring a sumptuous blend of pizza sauce, mozzarella, and an assortment of meats including capicola, hard salami, and Italian sausage. For something different, the Gyros Pizza marries tender gyros meat with fresh toppings and a delightful tzatziki dressing.
- Specialty Subs: The selection of specialty subs is equally impressive. The Pizza Sub combines the best of both worlds with its combination of ham, pepperoni, and provolone, melted to perfection. Meanwhile, the Chicken B.L.T sub is a hearty delight, layered with chicken, crispy bacon, and fresh veggies.
- Wings: And let's not forget about the wings! Pauly's offers both traditional and boneless wings, perfect for sharing. With a variety of flavors to choose from, these crispy golden bites are a satisfying addition to any meal.
Customer reviews speak volumes about their experience. Local patrons rave about the "fantastic pizza" and "great beer wall", often mentioning how the "kids loved it"—a testament to Pauly's ability to cater to families. One particularly impressed customer noted that it would be "their new go-to pizza place." This sentiment resonates with many who have discovered the joy of dining at Pauly's.
Don’t miss out on trying the renowned potato bacon soup, often described as the "BEST" by long-time customers. Whether you're here for a casual night out, a family feast, or a quick lunch, Pauly's Pizzeria & Sub Co. is a destination that promises delightful dishes and cherished moments.
So, if you find yourself in Rapid City and longing for a slice of authentic goodness, look no further. Pauly's Pizzeria & Sub Co. invites you to indulge in their incredible menu and experience the warmth of a community favorite.